Guides

Should you pop a pimple? What to do instead

Why dermatologists say hands off, what popping can do to a breakout (and the marks it leaves), and what to do instead for a whitehead or a deep, painful bump.

By Clear Path · Published · About 7 minutes · Educational only

The short answer
  • Don’t pop it. The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) says pimple popping is a job for a dermatologist, and the NHS says not to pick or squeeze spots.
  • Why: squeezing often pushes what’s inside deeper into the skin. That can make the spot more noticeable and more painful, and it raises the risk of infection, scars, and dark spots.
  • Instead: hands off, ice for a sore spot, a warm, damp washcloth for a deep one, a hydrocolloid patch to cover it, and a thin layer of an over-the-counter acne product.
  • Get help: see a dermatologist for deep, painful, or scarring breakouts, or spots that keep coming back.

A pimple that’s sitting right on your chin before a big day is hard to ignore, and popping it can feel like the fastest fix. The AAD’s advice is blunt: if you have a pimple you’re about to pop, stop. This guide explains why, in plain language based on AAD and NHS pages you can check yourself, and lays out what to do instead so the spot (and the mark it might leave) has the best chance of fading quietly.

Why you shouldn’t pop a pimple

The AAD points out that squeezing a pimple looks simple, but doing it without scarring or infection takes proper technique and sterile tools. When people pop pimples at home, it says, these side effects are likely:

  • Deeper inflammation. Squeezing often pushes some of the pimple’s contents deeper into the skin instead of out. That increases inflammation, which can make the spot more noticeable.
  • More pain. Some people end up with a sorer spot than they started with.
  • Infection. Your hands carry bacteria, and an open, squeezed pimple gives them a way in.
  • Scars. The AAD’s acne-scar page explains that picking, popping, scratching, or squeezing increases inflammation, and the more inflamed the skin, the more likely a scar. It lists popping and picking among the things that make some people more likely to scar than others.
  • Dark spots and slower clearing. The AAD’s acne tips note that picking, popping, or squeezing makes acne take longer to clear and raises the risk of dark spots called post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation (PIH).

The NHS keeps it to one line: don’t pick or squeeze spots, because this can cause scars.

Popping and the marks acne leaves

If dark marks are what bother you most, hands-off matters even more. A popped pimple is a small injury to the skin, and the AAD explains that dark spots often show up when a pimple clears or a skin injury mends. In its words, the hyperpigmentation tends to fade in time if you don’t re-injure your skin, which is exactly what repeated picking does.

It helps to know which kind of mark you’re looking at:

  • A flat spot of color (brown, purple, or darker than your skin) is usually PIH, not a scar. The AAD says a spot a few shades darker than your natural skin tone usually fades within 6 to 12 months once what’s causing it stops; color that sits deeper in the skin can take years.
  • An indent or a raised bump is an acne scar. The AAD says these can fade but rarely go away completely on their own, and a board-certified dermatologist can help. More on telling them apart and what helps marks fade: how to fade acne marks.

Daily sunscreen is part of the plan either way. The AAD says sunscreen can prevent new dark spots and help existing ones clear, and suggests a tinted, broad-spectrum SPF 30+ formula with iron oxide for darker skin tones. Our guide on sunscreen for acne-prone skin covers what to look for on the label.

Not sure where to start with breakouts or marks?

Our free quiz asks eight quick questions and suggests a starting point, plus a base routine screened for artificial fragrance and pore-clogging ingredients. It takes about two minutes, it’s not a diagnosis, and there’s no credit card.

Take the free quiz

What to do instead of popping

These steps come from the AAD’s pages on pimple popping and on deep, painful pimples.

  1. Keep your hands away from your face. The AAD notes that touching, picking, and popping can all worsen acne. If you pick without noticing, a cover can help (see step 4). Stress can make picking harder to resist; see does stress cause acne?.
  2. Use ice for a sore spot. The AAD suggests ice for painful acne, especially nodules and cysts, because it reduces inflammation.
  3. Use a warm, damp washcloth for a deep bump. For a deep, painful pimple, the AAD suggests holding a clean, warm, damp washcloth on it for 10 to 15 minutes, three times a day, to help bring it closer to the surface. Use a fresh washcloth each time, and still don’t squeeze.
  4. Cover it with a hydrocolloid patch. The AAD notes that a hydrocolloid acne patch, sold over the counter, can be applied to protect the skin. It also keeps fingers off. Which spots patches suit and how long to leave one on: do pimple patches work?
  5. Apply a thin layer of an acne product. The AAD lists over-the-counter options with adapalene, azelaic acid, benzoyl peroxide, or salicylic acid, and warns that using too much can irritate skin more. Our guide on benzoyl peroxide or salicylic acid explains which tends to suit which kind of breakout. The AAD also suggests spreading acne products over all acne-prone skin, not just the spot.
  6. Keep the rest of your routine gentle. Wash twice a day and after sweating with a gentle cleanser and your fingertips, without scrubbing; see how often to wash your face with acne.
  7. Give it time. The AAD says acne products take time to work: if you don’t see results in 4 to 6 weeks, a dermatologist can help. Switching products every few days can irritate skin; our guide on how long to try a new skincare product walks through a fair test.

Whiteheads, blackheads, and deep pimples

What to do instead of popping, by type of spot
What you seeHands-off optionWhen a dermatologist comes in
Whitehead or blackheadLeave it; a thin layer of salicylic acid or adapalene; a hydrocolloid patch to cover a whiteheadThe AAD describes acne extraction with sterile instruments, usually offered when other options haven’t cleared the skin
Red, sore pimpleIce; a thin layer of benzoyl peroxide; hands offIf breakouts keep coming back after weeks of a steady routine
Deep, painful bump (nodule or cyst)Never squeeze; warm, damp washcloth 10–15 minutes three times a day; ice for painIf it doesn’t go away or you get several; the AAD notes dermatologists can inject a single cyst or nodule, or drain it with sterile tools

The AAD notes these in-office procedures aren’t needed for every blemish, and that acne often clears with the right products and skin care. They are simply the safe version of what popping tries to do.

When to see a dermatologist

Hands-off habits help, but they have limits. The AAD suggests seeing a dermatologist for deep blemishes (cysts and nodules) that can leave scars, acne that hasn’t cleared with products you can buy without a prescription, or acne that makes you uncomfortable. It also notes that deep, painful pimples that don’t go away, or several at once, are a reason to book a visit. The NHS suggests seeing a GP if self-care isn’t helping, if you have lots of spots or they are deep, painful, or scarring, if you notice signs of a skin infection such as hot, swollen, red skin, or if acne is affecting your mental health.

FAQ

Should I pop my pimple?

The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) says no: only a dermatologist should do it. Popping at home often pushes some of what’s inside the pimple deeper into the skin, which increases inflammation and can make the spot more noticeable and more painful. The NHS gives the same advice: don’t pick or squeeze spots, because it can cause scars.

What happens if you pop a pimple?

According to the AAD, popping a pimple yourself raises the risk of permanent acne scars, more noticeable and more painful acne, and infection from the bacteria on your hands. The AAD also notes that picking, popping, or squeezing makes acne take longer to clear and increases the risk of dark spots called post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation.

Is it okay to pop a whitehead that has come to a head?

The AAD’s guidance doesn’t make an exception for whiteheads. It describes acne extraction—removing blackheads and whiteheads with sterile instruments—as something a dermatologist does, usually when other options haven’t cleared the skin. At home, the AAD suggests keeping your hands off and notes that a hydrocolloid acne patch can be used to protect the skin.

What can I do instead of popping a deep, painful pimple?

The AAD suggests not trying to pop it at all. Instead, hold a clean, warm, damp washcloth on it for 10 to 15 minutes, three times a day, to help bring it closer to the surface; use ice to ease pain and swelling; apply a thin layer of an over-the-counter product with adapalene, azelaic acid, benzoyl peroxide, or salicylic acid; and consider a hydrocolloid patch. If it doesn’t go away, or you get several deep, painful pimples, the AAD suggests seeing a board-certified dermatologist.

I already popped it. What now?

Leave it alone from here on. The AAD notes that every time you touch, pick, or pop, you can worsen acne, and that a dark spot left by a skin injury tends to fade over time if you don’t re-injure the skin. Keep your routine gentle and wear sunscreen. If the area becomes hot, swollen, and red, the NHS lists that as a possible sign of skin infection and suggests seeing a GP.

Will the mark from a popped pimple go away?

It depends on what it is. The AAD explains that a flat spot of color left after acne clears is usually post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, not a scar; a spot a few shades darker than your skin usually fades within 6 to 12 months once the cause stops, while deeper discoloration can take years. Acne scars (indents or raised marks) can fade but rarely go away completely on their own, and a dermatologist can help.

Want a steady, hands-off routine laid out?

Start with the free quiz. If you’d like the full plan, the Clear Path 30-Day Starter Protocol is a $39 personalized PDF with your AM/PM routine, a week-by-week plan for starting one active slowly, and a printable tracker. It’s education, not medical care, and results vary.

Take the free quiz See what’s in the protocol

Sources

Educational only. This guide is general information, not medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment, and it doesn’t replace care from a dermatologist or licensed healthcare provider. Results vary. Patch test new products and stop use if irritation occurs. Links to the AAD and NHS are for reference; neither endorses Clear Path. This guide has no product or affiliate links. Clear Path sells a $39 digital guide; see our Disclosures.